And now, a bit more about my holiday. To begin with anyway.
For several months now, I have been booked to go on holiday with my boyfriend and his parents for the last two weeks in September. We’re going to Portugal. And by coincidence, we’re going to Praia de Luz. For anyone not living on this planet, that’s the resort from which Madeleine McCann was abducted.
For those currently inhabiting Earth, it’s been hard to escape the carpet bombing that has been the media coverage of this incident (although, I know a few who have managed it, but they’re people who don’t always know what day it is). And much as I hate to the contribute to the saturation of this subject, I really feel I must.
I would like to say I am strenuously trying to avoid the journalistic trap of having read a few blog comments on the internet and from there extrapolating the entire spectrum of opinions of the general public; but it would seem there are some people out there who think the media coverage has been appalling.
I agree with you, whoever you are. Who needs continuous updates telling us nothing has happened? No one, obviously. I was discussing this with a friend who said the media enjoyed weaving non-existent narratives in order to suck people in to the content being provided.
He may be right, but I’m still not sure of the reasons for this. Viewer figures to lure in advertisers with lucrative contracts? A chance to focus on one story so we don’t have to invest time and effort on reporting anything else? Whatever the reason, it’s a poor show, especially from an institution like the BBC, which has guaranteed funding from the licence fee.
A lot of the comments I read make the point that if the McCanns were black/poor/disabled/one-legged cockneys with eyepatches they would have been pilloried in the press as inadequate parents whose remaining children should be taken into care. I think (stress on think) I have even come across the same sentiments expressed by media commentators.
Whoever holds this opinion, it potentially suggests two things:
1. The McCanns are actually bad parents and we should stop beatifying them as suffering victims just because they are white GPs with good salaries.
2. The media is racist and should spend more time lambasting these criminally inept examples of awful parenthood.
(Incidentally, if some commentators have intuited that sections of the media might be a little prejudiced, there’s cause for hope, no?)
However, I wish to propose an alternative view:
1. The McCanns are not bad parents.
2. By extension, if the same thing had happened to a black or working class family, the media would be entirely wrong to condemn them.
Let me explain: I do not believe leaving your children in an apartment a few minutes away from where you are eating dinner is a hanging offence. I don’t have children of my own, so I can’t comment from experience; I can’t say whether I would or would not do this myself.
But, the McCanns were checking on their children regularly. They hadn’t gone on holiday leaving the children in a different country as some neglectful parents have done in the past.
Madeleine was in the apartment and then she was not. For her to have been abducted, someone has to have been watching, waiting, for a time when Kate and Gerry McCann were not there. We should be condemning that person. They planned this, maybe only on the spur of the moment, but they were the one who abducted Madeleine. It’s ridiculously obvious to say this, but if they hadn’t stolen the little girl away, she would still be with her parents.
I think at best, Kate and Gerry McCann were naïve. It is very easy to slip into the trap of thinking: “Here I am on holiday in a nice, family resort, what possible dangers can there be?” I know I sometimes feel detached from a country I’m visiting. Not in a way that means I don’t enjoy myself. But I’m a visitor, somehow I’m protected. Of course this is ridiculous and bad things can happen anywhere, but I am glad the media has been restrained enough not criticise them too harshly. I can only cross my fingers and hope that had the family been different, less what one poster on the BBC website called “mediagenic”, the condemnation would have been as muted.
Unfortunately, the mere fact of Madeleine’s disappearance has only contributed to the climate of paranoia over paedophiles in this country. This paranoia creates a fertile soil in which accusations of failure to protect a young girl from rampaging sex offenders can sprout. I just hope such accusations continue to be in the minority, as the reality surrounding child abuse and abduction has very little to do with the media line on this subject.
And until a young black child goes missing in similar circumstances, we’ll just have to wait and see whether it’s only white middle class prejudice holding the vitriol back.